Mayfield Dairy Reviews

So... I tried this twice and both times the milk tasted off and went sour way before the date on the carton. I’m probably not going to buy it again

Made checking for milk allergens quick and painless.

I was just on mayfielddairy.com recently because I wanted to check the nutrition info before picking something up, and for the most part it did what I needed. The labels were right there, and I could find calories, sugar, fat, and serving size without having to click around forever.

The thing that stuck with me most, probably because I just looked at it, was how much sugar some of the products had compared with what I expected. It made me second-guess a couple of choices. Overall the site is fine, but I do wish it were easier to compare items side by side

The milk tasted kind of sour to me, and it was disappointing. Definitely not something I’d buy again.

Mayfield Dairy is usually solid, and I do like a lot of their regular flavors. The basics never really let me down. I just wish they mixed things up more with seasonal or fun flavors, because it starts to feel like the same choices every time. I’m also always a little wary of trying something new if it looks overhyped, because I hate feeling like I got fooled by fancy packaging or a limited-time label. Overall, it’s good, just could use more variety.

I’ve picked up Mayfield milk quite a few times now, it’s been fresh every time I open it. No weird smell, no off taste, and it holds up well in the fridge. It’s not something I expected to care about that much, but it does make a difference. So yeah, I guess I’ll keep buying it.

I’ll admit, I sometimes grumble about this store, but I also keep going back because they almost always have the milk I like in stock near me. It’s nothing fancy, but that’s kind of all I need

I tried using Mayfield Dairy to look up products and store info, but it was frustrating. The site felt slow and clunky, and I was expecting things to respond a lot faster. Some of the menus didn’t take me where I thought they would, and pages loaded strangely on my phone. After a few minutes, I just gave up. Not a great experience.

I tried using the Mayfield Dairy store locator to track down a flavor near me, and... it was okay. It showed a couple of stores, but when I got to one of them, they didn’t actually have it. Another store did, so it wasn’t completely wrong or anything, just... not as up to date as I’d hoped. It’d be really nice if it were more accurate before you make the trip.

I actually really liked this overall. It’s super smooth and creamy without feeling too heavy, which is exactly what I was hoping for. My only complaint is that it doesn’t stay soft for very long. If that doesn’t improve, I’d consider trying a different brand, but for now I’d still say it’s good.

I actually think the ingredients are solid for the most part. I know everyone has different taste preferences, but a couple of the flavors did come across a little too sweet for me. Still, it’s not like they’re bad or anything

I’ve always thought of them as a name I could count on, but my last few experiences have been kind of hit or miss. When it’s good, it’s really good, but the inconsistent quality makes me a little less confident each time.

I ordered from Mayfield Dairy and the packaging seemed really solid to me. Everything showed up cold, sealed up well, and there weren’t any leaks or weird messes to deal with, so I was happy when I opened it.

I’m giving it 4 stars only because one carton had a little dent on the corner, but maybe I’m being overly picky since it didn’t affect the product at all. Overall I’d still order again.

I tried reaching out and ended up waiting a few days just to get a reply that didn’t really help much. It was frustrating

I used to really enjoy Mayfield ice cream, so it was a fun little surprise when the last couple tubs were more icy than creamy. The flavor was weak too, almost like they’d been hanging out in the freezer a bit too long. It’s not the worst ice cream I’ve ever had, so there’s that, but for the price I definitely expected something a little better. I probably won’t be rushing to buy it again anytime soon

I do like Mayfield and it tastes good, but the prices have been feeling a bit high lately. I still pick it up sometimes, but I’m not always sure it feels worth it for the price, if that makes sense.

I don’t know, maybe I’m picky about stuff like this, but every jug I’ve bought has tasted exactly how I expect it to. No weird batches, no off flavor, nothing where you take a sip and go, “wait, what happened?” It’s just been consistently good for me so far.